Apoptosis in lupus nephritis patients: a study of Bcl-2 to assess glomerular and tubular damage
Egyptian Rheumatology and Rehabilitation volume 50, Article number: 20 (2023)
Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is an immune-mediated disease, due to exposure of self-antigens, through impairment of apoptosis and failure of lymphocytic tolerance. Impaired regulation of the pro- and anti-apoptotic gene products which coordinate programmed cell death may result in autoreactive B and T cells and autoimmunity. Genetically engineered mice that over-express the anti-apoptotic molecule Bcl-2, B cell lymphoma 2 (Bcl2) in B-lymphocytes advance a lupus-like illness. Lupus nephritis (LN) is one of the most serious manifestations of this autoimmune disorder. Glomerulonephritis (GN) is caused by either impaired regulation of apoptosis and/or clearance of apoptotic cells leading to a T cell-mediated autoimmune reaction with initiation of pathological immune complex deposits.
To evaluate the correlation between Bcl2 glomerular and tubular expression and pathological findings and laboratory data in different types of SLE GN.
Compared to the control group, patients with lupus nephritis have significantly higher glomerular, interstitial and tubular expression level (P value < 0.001). BCL2 expression was positively correlated with serum anti-ds-DNA, urine 24-h protein and with the chronicity index. All LN patients had significant glomerular, interstitial and tubular deposits of BCL2, P value < 0.001, P value 0.004, and P value 0.03, respectively.
The intrinsic pathway of apoptosis interferes not only with the pathogenesis of lupus glomerulonephritis but also interferes with the pathogenesis of tubulointerstitial lupus nephritis. tubulointerstitial lesions may not only be a result of glomerular injury but also a significant factor in lupus nephritis.
Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a prototype of immune-mediated disorders. The suggested pathological mechanism is due to exposure of self-antigens secondary to failure of apoptosis and lymphocytic tolerance, with resultant pathogenic autoreactive cell populations . Impaired regulation of the pro- and anti-apoptotic gene products which coordinate programmed cell death could lead to autoreactive B and T cells and autoimmunity . Genetically engineered mice that over-express the anti-apoptotic molecule Bcl-2 (B cell lymphoma 2) in B-lymphocytes advance a lupus like illness [3, 4].
Lupus nephritis (LN) is considered one of the main manifestations of this autoimmune disorder. Lupus nephritis is linked to intraglomerular cell apoptosis, which results in the exposure of nucleosomal contents, which serves as an activator for autoantibodies formation. Glomerulonephritis is caused by either impaired apoptosis or defective clearance of apoptotic bodies which causes nucleosome exposure, activation of antigen-presenting cells, and T cell-mediated reaction with the initiation of pathological immune complexes with subsequent complement fixation, activation, perpetuated inflammation and cellular activation .
Secondary SLE tubulo-interstitial nephritis (TIN) may be masked by GN, however it has major pathogenetic impact on renal outcome. The International Society of Nephrology/Renal Pathology Society (ISN/RPS) does not include SLE TIN in its schema of renal lupus classification and management. The pathogenesis of secondary SLE TIN was considered as a sequela of GN, or non-immunologic, i.e., a nonspecific injury in the tubular and interstitial tissue following advanced glomerular injuries, disregarding the main etiology . Despite the frequency of TIN, its possible clinical value, and imperative pathogenesis, research on this subject is quite scarce, in contrast to the extensive studies on lupus GN. Hence, we proposed that tubulointerstitial pathology may not only be a consequence of glomerular injury, but also an important influencer in lupus nephritis. The present study aims to evaluate the correlation between Bcl 2 glomerular and tubular expression, pathological findings and laboratory data in different types of SLE GN.
Patients and methods
This study included 30 patients with SLE renal involvement fulfilling the criteria of The Systemic Lupus International Collaborating Clinics (SLICC) group . A thorough clinical assessment was done with lab assessment of anti-ds-DNA titre and was measured by enzyme linked immune sorbent assay (ELISA). Other lab investigations; CRP, CBC, serum creatinine, BUN, serum C3, and C4, urine examination, and 24-h urinary protein. Renal biopsy specimens were obtained from all patients. A control group of 30 normal renal biopsies was attained from normal renal tissue in proximity to neoplasms from nephrectomy samples. We excluded patients who have age of less than 18 years and patients with antiphospholipid syndrome. All patients with infections and/or malignancies. The Histopathology classification of lupus nephritis, including activity and chronicity indices according to ISN/RPS 2003 Classification of lupus nephritis . All included patients signed informed consent for their participation in this study. The study was approved by the local ethics committee, numbered (FMASU R 74a \ 2022) and a written informed consent was taken from each participant.
Immunohistochemical staining was performed to all the patients by mice monoclonal antibodies for BCL2 (clone 124, Bcl-2; Dako Corporation, CA, USA) using avidin-biotin immune peroxidase technique. Peroxidase blocking solutions were applied for 15 min on tissue specimens from formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded specimens for blocking endogenous peroxidases. The specimens were then embedded in citrate buffer and put for 9 min in a microwave at 80 °C, for antigen collection. After cooling, incubation of the slides overnight with the diluted primary antibodies (1:25) was done. Then, diaminobenzidine (DAB) chromogen solution was added and counterstaining was done with Mayer’s hematoxylin. Positive and negative control was included in each run.
The immunohistochemical evaluation for each case was done by examination of the section to localize and detect the distribution of staining. The scoring system was applied as follows: 1+ mild intensity/ focal or diffuse distribution. 2+ moderate intensity/focal or diffuse distribution. 3+ marked intensity/ focal or diffuse distribution.
The collected data were coded, tabulated, and statistically analyzed using IBM SPSS statistics (Statistical Package for Social Sciences) software version 28.0, IBM Corp., Chicago, USA, 2021. Quantitative data were tested for normality using the Shapiro-Wilk test, then described as mean ± SD (standard deviation) as well as minimum and maximum of the range, and then compared using an independent t test. Qualitative data are described as numbers and percentages and compared using Fisher’s exact test. Correlations of the studied markers’ grades were done using Spearman’s test. The level of significance was taken at p value ≤ 0.05 was significant, otherwise was non-significant.
Regarding the demographic data of all our cases, the patient’s group had a mean age of 26.4 ± 8.8 years with 28 females and 2 males. F:M ratio was 14:1. While the control group had a mean age of 28.1 ± 6.1 years. There was no significant difference between the patients and the control group as regards age and sex. A summary of the Laboratory results of our patients showed: Table 1.
The pathology samples of our patients showed: according to (ISN/RPS) 2003 Classification of Lupus Nephritis, there were 4 patients (13.3%) with stage II (mesangial proliferative LN), 7 patients (23.3%) with class III (Focal LN), 14 patients (46.7%) with class IV (diffuse LN), 3 patients (10.0%) with class V (membranous LN), and 2 patients (6.7%) with class VI (advanced sclerosing LN). the mean ± SD of the activity index was (7.6 ± 4.8) while the chronicity index was (5.5 ± 3.5) (Table 2).
Bcl2 immuno-histochemical staining results
Bcl2 staining was found in the renal tubular epithelial cells of three of the 30 control cases (faint + 1 deposits) (Fig. 1).
Bcl2 staining was observed in the glomerular tuft’s mesangial cells, within the cellular crescents, inflammatory cells were found in the interstitium, and the tubules, in addition to other sites where it is normally found (Fig. 2). Compared to the control group, patients with lupus nephritis have significantly higher glomerular, interstitial and tubular expression level than the control group (P value < 0.001).
This study also correlated laboratory findings with Bcl-2 renal deposition and found significant positive correlation between BCL-2 histologic expression (tubular, interstitial, and glomerular) and serum anti-ds-DNA titre and urine 24-h protein. However, BCL-2 had no significant correlations with serum creatinine levels. The study also compared BCL2 expression in relation to activity and chronicity indices and found a significantly positive correlation between glomerular, interstitial, and tubular BCL-2 (p < 0.001, P = 0.009, and p < 0.001) and the Chronicity Index. While there were no significant correlations with activity index (Table 3).
All the patients of LN had significant glomerular, interstitial and tubular deposits of BCL2, (P value < 0.001), (P value 0.004), and (P value 0.03), respectively (Graph 1).
Comparing BCL2 deposition in the different classes of LN: the most prominent findings were in class IV cases, the biggest number of our patients belonged to this group, 14 cases; seven of which had +1 glomerular deposits, while the other seven had + 2 deposits in the glomerulus. Regarding interstitial deposits 9 of the cases had + 1 (64.29%), and only one case had + 2 (7.14%). On the other hand, tubular deposits were evident in 12 of the 14 cases (85.71%), 5 of which had + 1 deposits and 7 of them had +2 deposits (Fig. 3).
SLE is an immune-mediated disease characterized by a cellular and humoral immune reaction to self-proteins with consequent deposition of immune complexes in the different organs with resultant impairment of function [1, 2]. LN is one of the most serious complications affecting lupus patients and a major mortality and morbidity cause. It mainly affects young adults especially females as was found in this study, where the mean age of patients was 26.4 ± 8.8 years, female to male ratio (14: 1 ratio) .
In this study, we investigated one of the intrinsic pathways of apoptosis; bcl2; and its glomerular, tubular, and interstitial expression in LN. Bcl2 deposits were absent from the glomeruli and interstitial tissue of the normal kidney tissue (control group), and its presence was evident only in a few number of cases within the epithelial cells of their renal tubules which was documented in previous studies [5, 8, 10].
In this study, the expression of the anti-apoptotic Bcl-2 (glomerular, tubular, and interstitial) was statistically significantly in lupus patients compared to the controls. This confirms a previous study by Soto et al. , who discovered a decrease in apoptosis in LN upon comparing it to the control group. They proposed that LN could be secondary to excessive proliferation without an equivalent increase in apoptosis. Accordingly, they concluded that apoptosis was reduced in LN. Additionally, Hosny et al. noticed that bcl2 intraglomerular immune expression in LN was increased and was significantly associated with class IV LN comparing it to other classes. The presence of intraglomerular bcl2 was also linked to higher levels of endocapillary proliferation and mesangial cells in proliferative glomerulonephritis . These findings are consistent with those of Uguz et al. , who found Bcl-2 in mesangial cells and occasionally in infiltrating leucocytes in LN. Because Bcl-2 inhibits apoptosis and promotes cell survival, its expression has been linked to glomerular proliferation, implying that Bcl-2 plays a role in the persistent proliferation of glomerular cells in various types of GN. Bcl-2 is an anti-apoptotic protein that has been found to be elevated in the glomeruli and serum of LN patients . Bcl-2 overexpression may play a part in glomerular hypercellularity and the survival of infiltrating leukocytes in the LN . Furthermore, LN renal cell patients showed excessive proliferation in absence of an equivalent increase in apoptosis [11, 13]. The results of this study support the role of the bcl2 protein in the survival of glomerular cells in human LN renal tissue, which contributes to persistent glomerular hypercellularity .
Tubulointerstitial inflammation (TII) is common in lupus nephritis, and the presence and severity of TII are a stronger predictor of renal failure than glomerular inflammation . In situ antigen-driven clonal expansion of B cells is a hallmark of TII in lupus nephritis, indicating that propagation of adaptive autoimmune responses occurs locally . In our study, the expression of Bcl-2 (tubular and interstitial) was significantly higher in lupus patients compared to the controls. This is in accordance with the findings of a previous study by Ko et al. , who discovered that Bcl-2 expression was significantly more common in renal tissues with severe interstitial inflammation. Bcl-2 was expressed by both B cells and T cells, these Bcl-2-expressing lymphocytes were primarily found in the tubulointerstitial space and at a lower frequency in the glomerulus. These findings were later confirmed at the mRNA level by laser capture. This study also compared the expression of BCL2 in the different classes of LN and showed that the most prominent expression of both the glomerular and interstitial deposits were in class IV cases. The other classes also showed prominent deposits in the tubules and the interstium, in addition to the glomerular deposits. These findings support the known concept from previous studies that class IV LN is considered the worst class histopathologically . It also shows the intense immune complex deposition disease in the histopathology of class IV LN, with its implications on disease severity.
Renal biopsies are frequently used in LN to evaluate the degree of renal involvement, provide a prognosis, and support therapeutic decisions. A higher risk of developing renal failure was linked to higher levels of tubulointerstitial nephritis. In contrast, the glomerular-based NIH activity index offered no prognostic information, and the ISN/RPS lupus nephritis classification was a poor predictor of prognosis . Scores of CI were reported to be more significant prognostic factors for renal failure than those of AI . In patients receiving conventional treatment, the AI scores might be less significant . In our study, we found significant positive correlations between glomerular, interstitial, and tubular BCL-2 expression and chronicity index while there were no significant correlations with activity index. The results of Ko and colleagues , who discovered a significant correlation between CI and interstitial inflammation, were in agreement with ours. They proposed that in-situ adaptive immune responses are associated with severe interstitial inflammation. Thus, in lupus nephritis, increased interstitial inflammation was associated with the dysregulation of apoptotic proteins, which led to the survival of autoreactive immune cells and maintained the disease’s persistent activity. In lupus nephritis, interstitial Bcl-2 expression functions as both a regulator of immune cell survival and a regulator of in situ immunity [4, 16]. Our study’s findings are comparable to those of Lee et al., who discovered that interstitial inflammation was significantly correlated with CI scores and that Bcl-2 positivity was significantly correlated with CI but not AI, concluding that in order to predict renal prognosis in lupus nephritis patients, it is crucial to assess the degree of tubulointerstitial inflammation, increasing tubulointerstitial nephritis severity was linked to a higher risk of developing renal failure . On the other hand, according to Fathi et al., the levels of serum Fas and Bcl-2 protein expression and the chronicity index are directly correlated. Due to circulating T and B lymphocytes with abnormally high Bcl-2 and Fas expression, lupus nephritis patients’ serum Bcl-2 and Fas protein levels increased. The direct correlation between the chronicity index, Bcl-2 protein levels, and Fas protein levels raises the possibility of a shared mechanism regulating the expression of these molecules and the emergence of pathological changes in lupus nephritis .
Another finding in our study was that serum anti-dsDNA which reflects the overall lupus activity. Urinary 24-h proteins, that reflects kidney function, had significant positive correlations with BCL-2 expressions (tubular, interstitial, and glomerular). While serum C3 and C4 had significant negative correlations with BCL2. On the other hand, BCL-2 had no significant correlations with serum creatinine levels [21, 22]. This implies that BCL2 expression detects early kidney damage especially the tubulointerstitial expression that is not included in ISN/RPS classification.
Our results are in accordance with those of Takemura et al., who found that the degree of proteinuria was correlated with the number of Bcl-2-positive cells . Our findings support those of Uguz et al. and Rodriguez-Lopez et al., who found no correlation between Bcl-2 and plasma Cr or BUN levels [12, 23]. In accordance with the study of Wakasugi et al. and Zabaleta et al., significant numbers of SLE cases with renal impairment and/or overt proteinuria have glomerular lesions linked to histopathological IC deposition in the mesangium. Both studies also noted during their extended follow-up periods, that these patients’ kidney function did not significantly deteriorate. These studies suggest that the tubulointerstitial compartment should be examined in the pathogenesis of this disease since seldom involvement of glomerular IC depositions is insufficient for the development of clinically relevant LN [24, 25]. Jeruc et al. found that TII correlated with proteinuria . Although there was no direct relationship between the GN and the quantification of proteinuria, yet proteinuria is considered the marker of glomerular ultrafiltration and tubulopathy . Protein overload activates the proximal tubular epithelial cells and up-regulates the gene of endothelin-driven factor and cytokines, leading to macrophage activation and tubular epithelial cells experiencing epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition (EMT), and eventually, fibrosis takes place. Complement activation is an essential mediator during this progression and TII may be caused directly by the activation of the complement in circulation or may be triggered by the local production of complement in the tubular lumen . In human LN, inflammatory cells have been shown to infiltrate the tubulointerstitium with germinal center-like structures formation containing in situ immunoglobulins (Ig) repertoire with B cell clonal expansion . Plasma cells secreting anti-dsDNA antibodies were mainly found in the kidney tubulointerstitium . These findings identify the tubulointerstitial compartment as an essential site of autoreactive B cell immunity in LN. IC deposits nearby the tubular basement membrane (TBM) causes activation of the complement system, more severe tubulointerstitial pathology, more active disease, and poor prognosis. tubular ICs are formed independently of ICs from the circulation and glomeruli [29,30,31].
Limitations to this study
Other pro-and anti-apoptotic markers should be studied and correlated with the clinical activity.
According to our hypothesis, the intrinsic pathway of apoptosis interferes not only with the pathogenesis of lupus glomerulonephritis but also interferes with the pathogenesis of tubulointerstitial lupus nephritis. Tubulointerstitial lesions may not only be secondary to glomerular injury but also a primary cause of lupus nephritis.
Availability of data and materials
We approve the availability of our data upon request.
B cell lymphoma 2
Enzyme linked immune sorbent assay
International Society of Nephrology/Renal Pathology Society
Systemic lupus erythematosus
Systemic Lupus International Collaborating Clinics
Cojocaru M, Cojocaru IM, Silosi I, Vrabie CD (2011) Manifestations of systemic lupus erythematosus. Maedica (Bucur) 6:330–336
Pickering MC, Botto M, Taylor PR, Lachmann PJ, Walport MJ (2000) Systemic lupus erythematosus, complement deficiency, and apoptosis. Adv Immunol 76:227–324
Strasser A, Whittingham S, Vaux DL, Bath ML, Adams JM, Cory S et al (1991) Enforced BCL2 expression in B-lymphoid cells prolongs antibody responses and elicits autoimmune disease. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 88:8661–8665
Ko K, Wang J, Perper S, Jiang Y, Yanez D, Kaverina N et al (2016) Bcl-2 as a therapeutic target in human tubulointerstitial inflammation. Arthritis Rheum 68:2740–2751
Hosny G, Ismail W, Makboul R, Badary FAM, Sotouhy TMM (2018) Increased glomerular Bax/Bcl2 ratio is positively correlated with glomerular sclerosis in lupus nephritis. Pathophysiology 25:83–88
Guo Q, Lu X, Miao L, Wu M, Lu S, Luo P (2010) Analysis of clinical manifestations and pathology of lupus nephritis: a retrospective review of 82 cases. Clin Rheumatol 29:1175–1180
Hiramatsu N, Kuroiwa T, Ikeuchi H, Maeshima A, Kaneko Y, Hiromura K et al (2008) Revised classification of lupus nephritis is valuable in predicting renal outcome with an indication of the proportion of glomeruli affected by chronic lesions. Rheumatology (Oxford) 47:702–707
Mistry P, Kaplan MJ (2017) Cell death in the pathogenesis of systemic lupus erythematosus and lupus nephritis. Clin Immunol 185:59–73
Mak A, Mok CC, Chu WP, To CH, Wong SN, Au TC (2007) Renal damage in systemic lupus erythematosus: a comparative analysis of different age groups. Lupus 16:28–34
Takemura T, Murakami K, Miyazato H, Yagi K, Yoshioka K (1995) Expression of Fas antigen and Bcl-2 in human glomerulonephritis. Kidney Int 48:1886–1892
Soto H, Mosquera J, Rodriguez-Iturbe B, Henriquez La Roche C, Pinto A (1997) Apoptosis in proliferative glomerulonephritis: decreased apoptosis expression in lupus nephritis. Nephrol Dial Transplant 12:273–280
Uguz A, Gonlusen G, Ergin M, Tuncer I (2005) Expression of Fas, Bcl-2 and p53 molecules in glomerulonephritis and their correlations with clinical and laboratory findings. Nephrology (Carlton) 10:311–316
Fathi NA, Hussein MR, Hassan HI, Mosad E, Galal H, Afifi NA (2006) Glomerular expression and elevated serum Bcl-2 and Fas proteins in lupus nephritis: preliminary findings. Clin Exp Immunol 146:339–343
Song XF, Ren H, Andreasen A, Thomsen JS, Zhai XY (2012) Expression of Bcl-2 and Bax in mouse renal tubules during kidney development. PLoS One 7:e32771
Baker AJ, Mooney A, Hughes J, Lombardi D, Johnson RJ, Savill J (1994) Mesangial cell apoptosis: the major mechanism for resolution of glomerular hypercellularity in experimental mesangial proliferative nephritis. J Clin Invest 94:2105–2116
Shimizu A, Masuda Y, Kitamura H, Ishizaki M, Sugisaki Y, Yamanaka N (1998) Recovery of damaged glomerular capillary network with endothelial cell apoptosis in experimental proliferative glomerulonephritis. Nephron 79:206–214
Habas E, Khan F (2021) Lupus nephritis; pathogenesis and treatment update review
Hsieh C, Chang A, Brandt D, Guttikonda R, Utset TO, Clark MR (2011) Predicting outcomes of lupus nephritis with tubulointerstitial inflammation and scarring. Arthritis Care Res 63:865–874
Chang A, Henderson SG, Brandt D, Liu N, Guttikonda R, Hsieh C et al (2011) In situ B cell-mediated immune responses and tubulointerstitial inflammation in human lupus nephritis. J Immunol 186:1849–1860
Jin LS (2022) Interstitial Inflammation in the ISN/RPS 2018 Classification of Lupus Nephritis Predicts Renal Outcomes and is Associated With Bcl-2 Expression. J Rheum Dis 29:232–242
Umeda R, Ogata S, Hara S, Takahashi K, Inaguma D, Hasegawa M et al (2020) Comparison of the 2018 and 2003 International Society of Nephrology/Renal Pathology Society classification in terms of renal prognosis in patients of lupus nephritis: a retrospective cohort study. Arthritis Res Ther 22:260
Aringer M, Wintersberger W, Steiner CW, Kiener H, Presterl E, Jaeger U et al (1994) High levels of bcl-2 protein in circulating T lymphocytes, but not B lymphocytes, of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus. Arthritis Rheum 37:1423–1430
Rodriguez-Lopez AM, Flores O, Arevalo MA, Lopez-Novoa JM (1998) Glomerular cell proliferation and apoptosis in uninephrectomized spontaneously hypertensive rats. Kidney Int Suppl 68:S36–S40
Wakasugi D, Gono T, Kawaguchi Y, Hara M, Koseki Y, Katsumata Y et al (2012) Frequency of class III and IV nephritis in systemic lupus erythematosus without clinical renal involvement: an analysis of predictive measures. J Rheumatol 39:79–85
Zabaleta-Lanz M, Vargas-Arenas RE, Tapanes F, Daboin I, Atahualpa Pinto J, Bianco NE (2003) Silent nephritis in systemic lupus erythematosus. Lupus 12:26–30
Jeruc J, Jurcic V, Vizjak A, Hvala A, Babic N, Kveder R et al (2000) Tubulo-interstitial involvement in lupus nephritis with emphasis on pathogenesis. Wien Klin Wochenschr 112:702–706
Gunnarsson I, Sundelin B, Heimburger M, Forslid J, van Vollenhoven R, Lundberg I et al (2002) Repeated renal biopsy in proliferative lupus nephritis--predictive role of serum C1q and albuminuria. J Rheumatol 29:693–699
Tang Z, Lu B, Hatch E, Sacks SH, Sheerin NS (2009) C3a mediates epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition in proteinuric nephropathy. J Am Soc Nephrol 20:593–603
Chang M, Hsu NF, Lin TP (2011) In-situ mechanical characterization of Fe3O4 nanowires. J Nanosci Nanotechnol 11:5210–5214
Espeli M, Bokers S, Giannico G, Dickinson HA, Bardsley V, Fogo AB et al (2011) Local renal autoantibody production in lupus nephritis. J Am Soc Nephrol 22:296–305
Wilson HR, Medjeral-Thomas NR, Gilmore AC, Trivedi P, Seyb K, Farzaneh-Far R et al (2019) Glomerular membrane attack complex is not a reliable marker of ongoing C5 activation in lupus nephritis. Kidney Int 95:655–665
We are greatly indebted and deeply grateful to Professor Dr. Nadia Kamel, Professor of Physical Medicine, Rheumatology and Rehabilitation, Ain Shams University, for her precious and valuable advices, fruitful instructions and tremendous efforts.
No funding agency.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The study was approved by the local ethics committee of the Faculty of Medicine, Ain Shams University (FMASU R 74a\2022). An informed and written consent was taken from each participant.
Consent for publication
We confirm and approve to publish this article in the Egyptian Rheumatology and Rehabilitation journal.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Labib, H.S., Salman, M.I., Halim, M.I. et al. Apoptosis in lupus nephritis patients: a study of Bcl-2 to assess glomerular and tubular damage. Egypt Rheumatol Rehabil 50, 20 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1186/s43166-023-00186-w