Skip to main content

Table 5 Breakdown of statements of recommendations, its individual rank by experts’ opinion and level of agreement

From: Psoriatic arthritis treatment to the target: a consensus, evidence-based clinical practice recommendations for the management of psoriatic arthritis and its concomitant clinical manifestations

No.

Standard

Statement

LE

GoR

Mean Rate ±SD

% of agreement

Level of agreement

Recommendations of management

1

Patients with peripheral arthritis:

1.1. Start with csDMARDs at an early stage, with methotrexate in the dose of 15–25 mg/week preferred in those with relevant skin involvement for first-line treatment, MTX can be given orally, subcutaneous or Intramuscular route. Shared decision-making is advisable to agree which methotrexate administration form is preferable (oral vs subcutaneous vs intramuscular). Methotrexate should be taken for 12 weeks to judge the patient response to treatment. (LE:1 .GOR: A)

1.2. In patients with a contraindication to MTX or show intolerance; other csDMARDs including sulfasalazine, leflunamide, cyclosporine should be considered as first line of treatment strategy(LE: 1.GOR: A )

1.3. Methotrexate has been shown to increase the risk of developing liver fibrosis in patients with psoriasis, and should be used with caution in obese patients, patients who consume alcohol, and patients with other risk factors for hepatotoxicity such as diabetes and hepatitis. (LE:1 .GOR: A)

1.4. If biological therapy is not available; offer another cDMARDs (methotrexate, leflunomide, sulfasalazine, or cyclosporine) or in combination in a step-up strategy when the treatment target (remission or low disease activity) has not been achieved despite dose escalation within 3 months. (LE:4 .GOR: C )

1.5. Significant improvement [detected by PsA response criteria (PsARC) using tender and swollen joint count and patient and physician global assessment.] using csDMARDs should be achieved by 3 months. If no significant improvement has been achieved, by 3 months, adding another DMARD to MTX or use a different combination DMARD therapy is advised. DMARDs doses should be optimized to the maximum tolerable licensed levels (LE: 3.GOR: C)

1.6. Combined DMARD therapy means: MTX + SSZ, MTX + CSP, SSZ + CSP, or MTX + LEF (LE: 4 .GOR: C).

1.7. Consider oral non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs, including traditional NSAIDs and cox II selective inhibitors), when control of pain or stiffness is inadequate. Take account of potential gastrointestinal, liver and cardio-renal toxicity, and the person's risk factors, including age and pregnancy. (LE: 4 .GOR: D).

1.8. When using oral NSAIDs: (LE:1.GOR: A)

• Offer the lowest effective dose for the shortest possible time

• Offer a proton pump inhibitor (PPI)

• Review risk factors for adverse events regularly.

1.9. Local glucocorticoid injections should be considered when there is resisted oligo or monoarthritis. (LE:1 .GOR:A )

1.10. If the treatment target not achieved after 3 months of csDMARD therapy; switching to a bDMARD should be considered with or without MTX. (LE: 1.GOR: A)

1.11. Starting biological therapy from the first may be considered in severe cases (PASDAS score ≥ 5.4) with poor prognostic factors (LE: 2.GOR: B)

1.12. The cut-off point of starting biologic therapy is moderate Disease Activity: PASDAS: 3.2 to 5.4, and associated with adverse/poor prognostic factors (> 5 active joints, radiographic damage, elevated acute phase reactants, extra-articular manifestations especially dactylitis) functional disability (HAQ or equivalent) score > 2, US Doppler activity > 2 in > 3 joints. (LE: 5 .GOR: D)

1.13. First line biologic therapy: Use TNF-inhibitors, IL-17 inhibitor, IL-12/23 inhibitor, IL-23 inhibitor, CTLA4-ig, JAK inhibitor, or PDE4 inhibitor (IL-17 inhibitor, IL-12/23 inhibitor, or IL-23 inhibitor are advised/preferable if extensive skin affection identified by PASI score). (LE: 1.GOR: A)

1.14. Significant improvement (i.e., reaching minimal disease activity MDI, or low disease activity PASDAS: 1.9–3.2) using bDMARDs should be achieved by 3 months and the target should be achieved by 6 months. Treatment should be continued only if there is an adequate response at 6 months following initiation of therapy. (LE: 3.GOR: C)

1.15. If the patient has an inadequate initial response not reach even minimal disease activity (primary failure), switch out of therapeutic class considering a drug with other working mechanism is advised. (LE: 3.GOR: C)

1.16. In case of secondary failure to anti-TNF agent initially verify if the symptoms are due to active disease and confirm compliance. If verified, therapeutic drug monitoring is advised. In case of low drug levels with high antibodies, switching to another anti-TNF. However, if there is adequate drug level, no antibodies, it is advisable to switch out of the therapeutic class. (LE: 3.GOR: C)

1.17. In patients with persistent active disease, a tsDMARD, such as tofacitinib and PDE4-inhibitor (apremilast), should be considered. (LE: 3.GOR: C)

1.18. Treatment should normally be initiated with the least expensive drug (taking into account administration costs, required dose and product price per dose). This may need to be varied in individual cases due to differences in the mode of administration and treatment schedules. (LE: 5.GOR: D)

1.19. When switching from an anti-TNF drug (originator) to a biosimilar of that originator, one has to take into consideration that antidrug antibodies against the originator will cross-react with the biosimilar, causing treatment failure (LE:4 .GOR: D)

1.20. Non-pharmacological management (LE:4 .GOR: D)

• Physiotherapy: adults with PsA should have access to specialist physiatrist, with periodic review to: improve general fitness and encourage regular exercise, learn about the short-term pain relief provided by methods such as transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulators (TENS).

• Psychological interventions: offer psychological interventions (for example, relaxation, stress management, and cognitive coping skills) to help adults with PSA adjust to living with their condition.

• Diet therapy: Patients could be encouraged to follow the principles of a Mediterranean diet (more bread, fruit, vegetables and fish; less meat; and replace butter and cheese with products based on vegetable and plant oils, and it may be of value in management metabolic comorbidities.

8.42

±0.77

89.5

H

2

Patients with dactylitis:

2.1. Start with NSAIDs at an early stage

2.2. Local glucocorticoid injections should be considered when there is resisted dactylitis

2.3. csDMARDs (methotrexate, leflunomide, sulfasalazine or cyclosporine) may be tried in management of dactylitis for 3 months although csDMARDs have not been proven efficacious in treating these aspects of dactylitis.

2.4. If the treatment target not achieved after 3 months of cDMARD; adding or switching to a bDMARD should be considered.

2.5. First line biologic therapy: TNF-inhibitors, IL-17 inhibitor, IL-12/23 inhibitor, IL-23 inhibitor, CTLA4-ig, JAK inhibitor, or PDE4 inhibitor (IL-17 inhibitor, IL-12/23 inhibitor, or IL-23 inhibitor are more recommended if extensive skin affection)

2.6. Assess response to bDMARDs every month for 3 months, if inadequate response (not reach even minimal disease activity); switch between biologics is considered

2

B

8.47±0.77

100

H

3

Patients with enthesitis:

3.1 Start with NSAIDs at an early stage

3.2 Local glucocorticoid injections should be considered when there is resisted enthesitis

3.3 csDMARDs (methotrexate, leflunomide, sulfasalazine or cyclosporine) may be tried in management of enthesitis for 3 months although csDMARDs have not been proven efficacious in treating these aspects of enthesitis.

3.4 If the treatment target not achieved after 3 months of cDMARD; adding or switching to a bDMARD should be considered. Ultrasonographic assessments of the entheses should follow the Madrid Sonographic Enthesitis Index (MASEI)

3.5 First line biologic therapy: TNF-inhibitors, IL-17 inhibitor, IL-12/23 inhibitor, IL-23 inhibitor, CTLA4-ig, JAK inhibitor, or PDE4 inhibitor (IL-17 inhibitor, IL-12/23 inhibitor, or IL-23 inhibitor are more recommended if extensive skin affection)

3.6 Assess response to bDMARDs every month for 3 months, if inadequate response (not reach even low disease activity); switch between biologics is considered

3.7 Physiotherapy has an important issue in management of enthesitis.

2

B

8.21±1.31

89.5

H

4

Patients with axial affection:

4.1.Start with NSAIDs and physiotherapy at an early stage

4.2.treatment target (disease remission BASDAI < or ASDAS < 1.3) should be assessed monthly by BASDAI and ASDAS for 3 months

4.3. If the treatment target not achieved after 1 month; addition of a bDMARD should be considered (with the cut-point ASDAS value > 2.1 and (BASDAI value > 4((

4.4. First line biologic therapy: TNF-inhibitors, IL-17 inhibitor, or JAK inhibitor, (IL-17 inhibitor is more recommended if extensive skin affection(

4.5.In patients who fail to respond adequately to a bDMARD, (marked improvement in 3 months or reach target in 6 months switching to another bDMARD should be considered, including switching between TNFis.

4.6.Assess response to bDMARDs every month for 3 months, if inadequate response; switch between biologics may be considered after 6 months.

1

A

8.58±0.77

100

H

5

patients predominant skin or nail affection:

5.1.Start with topical (keratolytics, steroids, vitamin D analogues, emollients, calcineurin i) at an early stage

5.2.If the treatment target not achieved start csDMARDs (methotrexate, cyclosporine, acitretin, fumaric acid esters)

5.3.If the treatment target not achieved after 3 months of csDMARD; addition of a bDMARD should be considered as (TNF-inhibitors, IL-17 inhibitor, IL-12/23 inhibitor, IL-23 inhibitor, CTLA4-ig, JAK inhibitor, or PDE4 inhibitor(

5.4.IL-17 inhibitor, IL-12/23, or IL-23 inhibitor are more recommended if extensive skin affection.

5.5In patients who fail to respond adequately to a bDMARD, switching to another bDMARD, tsDMARD, or PDE4-inhibitor should be considered.

1

A

8.42±±0.76

100

H

6

Patients with comorbidities:

6.1.Inflammatory bowel disease:

6.1.1.Common medications are being used to treat both conditions with two issues; be cautious with NSAIDs as they may exacerbate IBD symptoms, etanercept was not shown to be effective in treatment of IBD. Also, caution should be exercised when prescribing IL-17 inhibitors to patients with IBD.

6.1.2.First line biological treatment are (TNF monoclonal antibodies, IL-12/23, IL-23 inhibitor, or JAK inhibitor.

6.1.3.In patients who fail to respond adequately to a bDMARD, switching to another bDMARD.

6.2.Uveitis

6.2.1.Using TNF monoclonal antibody is beneficial with special consideration to adalimumab and infliximab.

6.2.2.Topical treatment with corticosteroids and/or cyclosporine should be considered

6.3. Liver disease: extra caution should be used when prescribing NSAIDs, DMARDs especially patients using methotrexate with regular monitoring for liver function tests abnormalities.

6.4.Cardiovascular comorbidities: an association of methotrexate treatment with reduced cardiovascular risk has been found among patients with PsA. TNF inhibitors are associated with a significant lower risk of cardiovascular events with take in consideration TNF inhibitors issues in heart failure state grade III and IV.

Take in consideration that there is may be increased risk of serious heart-related events when using JAK inhibitors.

6.5.Regular monitoring of uric acid, blood pressure, and lipid profile during management of psoriatic arthritis is recommended.

2

B

8.53±0.77

100

H

  1. LE Level of evidence according to the Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine (CEBM) criteria, H high level of agreement, GoR grade of recommendations, PsA psoriatic arthritis, MTX methotrexate, bDMARDS biological disease modifying anti-rheumatic drugs. csDMARDs conventional synthetic disease modifying anti-rheumatic drugs, tsDMARDS target synthetic disease modifying anti-rheumatic drugs, PsARC PsA response criteria, SSZ Salphasalazine, LEF leflunamide, CSP cyclosporine, TNF tumor necrosis factor, IL interleukin, PDE4 phosphodiesterase-4, NSAIDs non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, PASDAS Psoriatic Arthritis Disease Activity Score, TENS transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation. Cs corticosteroids. JAKi janus kinase inhibitors